Shots - Health Blog
Mon March 5, 2012
Pet Therapy: How Animals And Humans Heal Each Other
Those of us who own pets know they make us happy. But a growing body of scientific research is showing that our pets can also make us healthy, or healthier.
That helps explain the increasing use of animals — dogs and cats mostly, but also birds, fish, and even horses — in settings ranging from hospitals and nursing homes to schools, jails and mental institutions.
Take Viola, or Vi for short. The retired guide dog is the resident canine at the Children's Inn on the campus of the National Institutes of Health in Bethesda, Maryland. The Inn is where families stay when their children are undergoing experimental therapies at NIH.
Vi, a chunky yellow Labrador retriever with a perpetually wagging tail, greets families as they come downstairs in the morning, as they return from treatment in the afternoon, and can even be "checked out" for a walk around the bucolic NIH grounds.
"There really isn't a day when she doesn't brighten the spirits of a kid at the Inn. And an adult. And a staff member," says Meredith Daly, the Inn's spokeswoman.
But Vi may well be doing more than just bringing smiles to the faces of stressed out parents and children. Dogs like Vi have helped launch an entirely new field of medical research over the past three decades or so.
The use of pets in medical settings actually dates back more than 150 years, says Aubrey Fine, a clinical psychologist and professor at California State Polytechnic University. "One could even look at Florence Nightingale recognizing that animals provided a level of social support in the institutional care of the mentally ill," says Fine, who has written several books on the human-animal bond.
But it was only in the late 1970s that researchers started to uncover the scientific underpinnings for that bond.
One of the earliest studies, published in 1980, found that heart attack patients who owned pets lived longer than those who didn't. Another early study found that petting one's own dog could reduce blood pressure.
More recently, says Rebecca Johnson, a nurse who heads the Research Center for Human/Animal Interaction at the University of Missouri College of Veterinary Medicine, studies have been focusing on the fact that interacting with animals can increase people's level of the hormone oxytocin.
"That is very beneficial for us," says Johnson. "Oxytocin helps us feel happy and trusting." Which, Johnson says, may be one of the ways that humans bond with their animals over time.
But Johnson says it may also have longer-term human health benefits. "Oxytocin has some powerful effects for us in the body's ability to be in a state of readiness to heal, and also to grow new cells, so it predisposes us to an environment in our own bodies where we can be healthier."
Animals can also act as therapists themselves or facilitate therapy – even when they're not dogs or cats.
For example, psychologist Aubrey Fine, who works with troubled children, uses dogs in his practice but also a cockatoo and even a bearded dragon named Tweedle.
"One of the things that's always been known is that the animals help a clinician go under the radar of a child's consciousness, because the child is much more at ease and seems to be much more willing to reveal," he says.
Horses have also become popular therapists for people with disabilities.
"The beauty of the horse is that it can be therapeutic in so many different ways," says Breeanna Bornhorst, executive director of the Northern Virginia Therapeutic Riding Program in Clifton, Va. "Some of our riders might benefit from the connection and the relationship-building with the horse and with their environment. Other riders maybe will benefit physically, from the movements, and build that core strength, and body awareness and muscle memory."
On a recent day, one of the therapeutic riding program's instructors – speech therapist Cathy Coleman – works one-on-one with 9-year-old Ryan Shank-Rowe, who has autism.
Well, not really one-on-one. The co-therapist in this session is a speckled pony named Happy.
"Walk on" says Ryan, and Happy obediently does. "Excellent," Coleman replies.
As the session progresses, Ryan makes Happy trot, weave in and out of poles, and even rides bareback, all the while answering Coleman's questions and keeping up a continual back-and-forth chatter.
Coleman says she used to see Ryan in a more formal office environment. But since he's started horseback riding, his speech has actually improved.
"I get greater engagement, greater alertness, more language, more processing, all those things," she says. "Plus, he's just really good at it."
And Ryan's mother, Donna Shank, says the riding has helped with more than just his speech.
"It's helped his following directions, some really core life skills about getting dressed and balance — which really translate to a lot of safety issues, too."
But not all the research is focused on the humans. "We want to know how the animals are benefitting from the exchange," says Rebecca Johnson of the University of Missouri.
Much of Johnson's research, for example, has focused on the value of dog-walking by studying volunteers who walk dogs at animal shelters. She even wrote a book, Walk a Hound, Lose a Pound.
Those programs have clearly helped people get healthier, she says. Not only do they increase their exercise while they're walking the dogs, "but it increases their awareness, so that they exercise more during the week."
But it turns out the program was also helping the dogs.
"What we found was that they were significantly more likely to be adopted if they were in the dogwalking group," she says, thanks to the additional exercise and socialization they were getting.
Johnson's now working on a new project with likely benefits for dogs and humans. Military veterans returning from Iraq and Afghanistan are providing shelter dogs with basic obedience training.
And while it's still early in the research, she says, one thing seems pretty clear: "Helping the animals is helping the veterans to readjust to being at home."
Now the research is getting an even bigger scientific boost.
The National Institutes of Health, with funding from pet food giant Mars, Inc., recently created a federal research program to study human-animal interaction. The program, operated through the National Institute for Child Health and Human Development, offers scientists research grants to study the impact of animals on child development; in physical and psychological therapeutic treatments, and on the effects of animals on public health, including their ability to reduce or prevent disease.
Johnson says it's critical to establish the scientific foundation for the premise that animals are good for people, even if that seems obvious.
"The last thing we want is for an entire field to be based on warm fuzzy feelings and not on scientific data," she says. "So it's very important that now the NIH is focused on this ... and it is helping scientists across the country like myself to be able to do our research."
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
So antibiotics may not always be good for your health. Owning a pet can be. Research suggests that your interaction with a pet can help you live longer, as NPR's Julie Rovner reports.
MEREDITH DALY: So this is the Children's Inn. Welcome.
JULIE ROVNER, BYLINE: Meredith Daly works at the Children's Inn on the campus of the National Institutes of Health in Bethesda, Maryland. It houses the families of children who are undergoing experimental therapies. The idea is to make the inn feel like an actual home. And one of the ways they do that is by having a resident dog. Meet Viola, or Vi for short.
DALY: Oh, she's giving you kisses.
ROVNER: Tonight, Vi is acting as the canine chaperone for about a half a dozen kids and parents in the inn's learning center. There's a lesson going on at the work table, but four-year-old Thelma Balmaceda is much more interested in Vi, who's sprawled on her back on the floor, wanting a belly rub.
Do you like the dog?
THELMA BALMACEDA: Yeah. I have a dog in my house.
ROVNER: What's your doggie's name?
ROVNER: Vi, who's a retired seeing-eye dog, has been a tremendous addition to the staff, says Daly. But Vi may well be doing more than just bringing smiles to the faces of stressed out parents and children.
Aubrey Fine says dogs like Vi have helped launch an entirely new field of medical research over the past three decades or so. He's a child psychologist and professor at Cal State Polytech University in Pomona, California.
AUBREY FINE: An animals' presence can reduce a person's stress level.
ROVNER: Fine uses a variety of animals, including dogs, birds and even a lizard in his own practice. While he says animals have been used to help patients dating back to the 1800s, it's only in the past few decades that scientists have been able to pinpoint how exactly they help.
For example, one of the first studies found that petting a dog can help reduce blood pressure in people with heart disease. And now several universities have centers that study human-animal relationships.
Rebecca Johnson is a nurse who heads the one at the University of Missouri, College of Veterinary Medicine.
REBECCA JOHNSON: The research evidence on the benefits of human-animal interaction for people is very compelling now.
ROVNER: She says one of the most important discoveries has been that interacting with an animal increases a person's level of the hormone oxytocin. That's good because oxytocin helps people feel happy and trusting. But that's not all.
JOHNSON: Oxytocin has some powerful effects for us in promoting the body's ability to be in a state of readiness to heal, and also to grow new cells, so it predisposes us to an environment in our own bodies where we can be healthier.
ROVNER: So being around animals clearly has health benefits. But animals can also act as therapists themselves.
CATHY COLEMAN: OK. Ryan let's go. Ready, up, down.
ROVNER: Nine-year-old Ryan Shank-Rowe has autism. Today he's working with a special therapist, a large speckled gray pony named Happy at the Northern Virginia Therapeutic Riding Program.
COLEMAN: Happy has stopped and we need her to go.
RYAN SHANK-ROWE: Walk on.
ROVNER: Cathy Coleman is Ryan's speech therapist. She used to see Ryan in an office. But as she jogs alongside Happy, Coleman says that the horseback riding actually helps Ryan talk more.
COLEMAN: I get greater engagement, greater alertness, more language, more processing, all those things.
ROVNER: And Ryan's mother, Donna Shank, says riding has helped with more than just speech.
DONNA SHANK: It's helped his following directions, some really core life skills about, you know, getting dressed and balance - which really translates to a lot of safety issues, too.
SHANK-ROWE: Down, up.
COLEMAN: Keep it going, buddy. Keep it going.
SHANK-ROWE: Down, up.
ROVNER: But sometimes it's not just people who benefit. Rebecca Johnson says some of the research is focused on the other end of the leash.
JOHNSON: We want to know how the animals are benefitting from the exchange.
ROVNER: For example, Johnson has studied volunteers who walk dogs at animal shelters. Those programs have clearly helped people get healthier, she says, but they've helped the dogs at the same time.
JOHNSON: They were significantly more likely to be adopted if they were in the dog walking group.
ROVNER: Johnson's now working on a new project with likely benefits for dogs and humans. Military veterans returning from Iraq and Afghanistan are providing shelter dogs with basic obedience training. And while it's still early in the research, she says, one thing seems pretty clear.
JOHNSON: Helping the animals is helping the veterans to readjust to being at home.
ROVNER: Now the field is about to get another big scientific boost. The National Institutes of Health recently established the first-ever program to fund human-animal interaction research. That could mean meaning that sometime in the not too distant future, rather than writing a prescription for a medication, your doctor may tell you to go pet your dog instead - or your cat.
Julie Rovner, NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
INSKEEP: And that's Your Health for this Monday morning. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.